Deputy Matt Carthy called on the justice minister to do the right thing and allow the establishment of a public enquiry.

Zigimantas Gridziuska was a criminal with 42 convictions who should have been in prison.

Deputy Carthy says Shane O'Farrell and his family was failed by the state,

Deputy Smith says there is a fundamental question that the scoping report does not answer.

According to Mr Herrick, a series of ineffective and unsuccessful inquiries have taken place over the years in relation to this case.

Deputy Matt Carthy says Zigimantas Gridziuska is solely responsible for the death of Shane O'Farrell, nobody else, and certainly not Shane himself.

Mr O'Farrell who was 23, died after a hit and run incident by a man who was on bail and had 42 previous convictions.